Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutReso 33-21 approving FY 21-22 MBFFA MOU (cjt)RESOLUTION NO. 33-21 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MORRO BAY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A TENTATIVE AGREEMENT AND SUCCESSOR MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE CITY OF MORRO BAY AND THE MORRO BAY FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, IAFF LOCAL 3725, FOR THE PERIOD OF JULY 1, 2020 THROUGH JUNE 30, 2022 THE CITY COUNCIL Morro Bay, California WHEREAS, the City of Morro Bay ("City") has, and continues to recognize, the Morro Bay Fire Fighters Association, IAFF Local 3725 ("MBFFA"), as the exclusive employee organization representing the City's fire fighting employees as defined in the parties in their labor agreements, for all matters concerning wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment; and WHEREAS, the current Memorandum of Understanding between the City and MBFFA, which was duly approved by the City Council on September 26 2017, expired by its own terms on June 30, 2020, and WHEREAS, the City and MBFFA subsequently met and conferred to negotiate a Side Letter Agreement to the MBFFA MOU 2017-2020 implementing a temporary salary reduction in light of the COVID-19 pandemic and thereafter jointly prepared and executed the Side Letter Agreement to the MBFFA MOU 2017-2020 (Side Letter Agreement), which was ratified by MBFFA on September 23, 2020 and approved by the City Council by Resolution No. 85-20 on September 24, 2020, and WHEREAS, the City and MBFFA have continued to negotiate a two-year agreement for the period of July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2022, with a five percent (5%) base salary increase cost of living adjustment for FY 21-22 and, in recognition for the financial and overall sacrifices made during the COVID-19 health emergency, also includes a potential one-time lump sum payment contingent upon satisfaction of specified financial terms and conditions; and WHEREAS, the City's labor relations representatives and MBFFA representatives successfully met and conferred to negotiate the two-year MOU between the parties, pursuant to both the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act ("MMBA") (Gov't Code Section 3500-3511) and the City's Employer -Employee Relations Resolution, Resolution No 08-17, and have jointly prepared and executed both the attached Tentative Agreement ("MBFFA MOU 2020-2022 Tentative Agreement') and successor MOU between the City and MBFFA, for the period July 1, 2020 through, and including, June 30, 2022 ("MBFFA MOU 2020-2022"), which was ratified by the MBFFA; and WHEREAS, both the MBFFA MOU 2020-2022 Tentative Agreement and MBFFA MOU 2020-2022 are subject to City Council acceptance and approval, which is made a part hereof by this reference; and WHEREAS, once approved by the City Council, the MBFFA MOU 2020-2022 shall become a binding agreement between the City and MBFFA. S OW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF MORRO BAY, CALIFORNIA, AS FOLLOWS: S ection 1. The above recitals are true and correct. S ection 2. The City Council approves, adopts and implements the MBFFA MOU 2020- 2022 Tentative Agreement between the City and MBFFA for the period of July 1, 2020 through, and including, June 30, 2022, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit 1. S ection 3. The City Council approves, adopts and implements the successor MOU between the City and MBFFA for the period of July 1, 2020 through, and including, June 30, 2022, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit 2. S ection 4. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this Resolution and enter it into the book of original resolutions. S ection 5. This resolution shall be effective immediately upon its passage and adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED, by the City Council of the City of Morro Bay, at a regular meeting thereof held on the 22nd day of June 2021, by the following vote: AYES' Headding, Addis, Barton, Davis, Heller NOES' None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None ATTEST: Cia4A. (FIAS91-- DANA SWANSON, City Clerk TENTATIVE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF MORRO BAY AND THE MORRO BAY FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, IAFF LOCAL 3725 FOR A SUCCESSOR MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING APRIL 12, 2021 The current Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the City of Morro Bay (City) and the Morro Bay Firefighters Association, IAFF Local 3725 (MBFFA or Association), Resolution No. 52-17, approved September 26, 2017, covering the period July 1, 2017 through June 30, 2020 (MBFFA MOU 2017-20), expired by its own terms on June 30, 2020. The MBFFA represents 12 total City employees, including 1 Firefighter, 1 Fire Marshal, 7 Engineer/Paramedics, and 3 Fire Captain/Paramedics. Pursuant to the Meyers-Milias-Brown Act ("MMBA") (Gov't Code Sections 3500 - 3511), the City and the Association have been in negotiations for a successor MOU since June of 2020 to present. During that negotiation time period, the parties negotiated, ratified and signed a Side Letter that was subsequently approved by City Council as Resolution No. 85-20 providing for a 5% salary reduction for represented employees commencing October 2020 and which continued through December 31, 2020. The City and the Association have reached a Tentative Agreement on the deal terms for a successor MOU, which is represented by this document. The following deal terms have been ratified by the Association, but remains subject to formal approval/adoption by the City Council per California Government Code Section 3505.1, which provides: "If a tentative agreement is reached by the authorized representatives of the public agency and a recognized employee organization or recognized employee organizations, the governing body shall vote to accept or reject the tentative agreement within 30 days of the date it is first considered at a duly noticed public meeting. A decision by the governing body to reject the tentative agreement shall not bar the fling of a charge of unfair practice for failure to meet and confer in good faith. If the governing body adopts the tentative agreement, the parties shall jointly prepare a written memorandum of understanding." All terms and conditions of the prior MBFFA MOU 2017--20 and Resolution No. 85 shall be maintained unless expressly modified or changed herein until the successor MOU is jointly prepared by the parties, ratified by the Association and accepted, approved and adopted by City Council, which shall then supersede and replace this Tentative Agreement. 01181.0001 /706162.2 1 TENTATIVE AGREEMENT DEAL POINTS S> bJecttzk X is ngM0Tl _ 0: Ali- > o auges to 0>Cr trcle 4., 4.5 New Information and per Orientation AB Hire 119 NEW new prior orientation urgent reasonably the the period hire employee, the representative employee's department and phone The the The designated writing mailing earlier date MBFFA's work, new MOU CITY hires of for to of need each or the of address, under shall each department, email, the hire new to list the home via at of the home with orientation will representative unless foreseeable. hit will representative employee name least that newly work explain thirty email notify or personal and was permitted phone ten location, receive there by (30) hired regarding following personal (10) not the will packet. work s title, MBFFA's new is new rights address, days MBFFA's numbers. Within first provide session unit in an email, a days home copy one after pay all the of e month will designated be bargaining the CITY with his/her provide mailing and job MOU. employees the the work numbers. to cell and in (1) all bargaining of cell orientation employee's including job location, employee hour to benefits The designated quai the personal and MBFFA members talk CITY a unit, name, home represented title, terly personal 01181.0001/706162.2 2 Notwithstanding the with telephone cellular personal birth form CITY information. pasties such all of the of a regal expenses, this to telephone any written and claims, home any email will number employee ding will employees employee to CITY, not address, indemnify address request demands, non mutually track or the provide number, personal liability -disclosure its foregoing said who and not home or to requests officers, fiom and damages, MBFFA arising of of on any hold date the agree be or has use CITY said The a employee whether that disclosed. harmless agents, and costs, out made MBFFA information shall the information Article. 6., 6.1 MBFFA [New Checkoff piovisions SB 866] Dues Dues per It withhold and insurance the regular who to individual signed authorizing agreed specifying each authorizing a MBFFA. member MBFFA MBFFA is check, provide agreed monthly is MBFFA deduction, MBFFA premiums that MBFFA CITY MBFFA the pay CITY CITY the group employee, individual amount CITY of and to collective of with dues to to from issue make will of exclusive the deduct initiation assessments, of program salaries has salary to As MBFFA, The deduction by be authorization dispute of MBFFA deducted any the the made MBFFA and MBFFA recognized employee authorizations a members the requests as membership and the authorization. pay well the the from not of majority general wages period by deduction organization, dues, of CITY the that as certifies an be the the all payment whose individual existence the benefit and such signed required in and/or CITY that to it a be unless MBFFA. shall a by deductions, other individual membership of shall CITY sponsored and of fees, from wages agrees each the authorizations member the is The provide terms copy hereby shall to maintain about payable member, for or arises dues membership each 01181.0001 /706162.2 3 amount of the individual deductions CITY does not accept responsibility for computing the amounts of deductions or for meeting payment dates, which may not coincide with established pay periods. CITY will issue a single check to the MBFFA for the total amount of deductions withheld from the individual employees' pay. The MBFFA will be responsible foi the accounting and disbursing of all such fiords received from CITY MBFFA will be responsible for properly notifying CITY of any changes in deductions, and will be the sole agent, through which CITY will act, in explaining, initiating, executing, or terminating the provisions of this Article. Such notification must be ieceived by the CITY at least two weeks prior to the effective date of the change. Also, such change notice must include a copy of the notice sent to the employees officially, telling them of the change. accordance with CITY procedures and provisions of applicable law from the salary of each employee whose name is provided by the MBFFA CITY does not accept responsibility foi computing the amounts of deductions or for meeting payment dates which may not coincide with established pay periods. CITY will issue a single check to the MBFFA for the total amount of deductions withheld from the individual employees' pay. The MBFFA will be responsible for the accounting and disbursing of all such funds ieceived from CITY. MBFFA will be responsible for properly notifying CITY of any changes in deductions, and will be the sole agent, through which CITY will act, in explaining, initiating executing, or terminating the provisions of this Article. Such notification must be received by the CITY at least two weeks prior to the effective date of the change. Also, such change notice must include a copy of the notice sent to the employees officially telling them of the change. 01181.0001/706162.2 4 7 2017 shall as the through otherwise term be provided from of June this July 30, Except provided MOU through shall as June herein, otherwise be 30, from the 2022 July specifically tern of 1, 2020, this Term Except specifically herein, 1 2020. MOU 8., 8.1 Renegotiations In wants successor party other, December January wiitten negotiations, full proposals MOU. commence March the and shall event to during 15, request Negotiations renegotiate 31, entire serve 1, no 2020. either 2020, the 2019 as later to written such upon period well its begin party to than a this as shall the its of In renegotiate such other December 2022 negotiations, entire amending shall the party commence event during its wiitten 15, shall 1, 2022. a either successor the 2021 MOU. serve well period request no party to later January upon Negotiations MOU, its wants of to than full the begin 31, to and written this MOU, amending as proposals as March 8., 8.3 Renegotiations Should unable on the expires, provisions shall and as or whichever a a September current effect new new remain to the all reach contract MOU until parties contract applicable of in full such is agreement occurs reached, 2020, be before MOU force time Should reach contract contract provisions remain such reached, whichever time agreement the in before expires or full as parties force new the occurs. on be MOU a current applicable and MOU unable new 30, shall effect is 2022, to until this 30, of September first this a all first 12 Sick Leave 12.5.2 Credits Leave -time date hours added Accrual above, employees, per to account shall the Sick after be .... for Increase for Sick by upon of and 2 full-time 31, tentative hours expiring/sunsetting Leave credit employees Accrual Council agreement per MOU City Credits month effective approval or December 2021. frill the 11.2 month 14., 14.2 Health Insurance For receive contribution, 2017, a required cafeteria MBFFA contribution as including follows: by shall plan the For receive contribution, minimum required 2020 a and cafeteria conhrbution by including Ca1PERS, 2021 plan MBFFA the follows: shall amount as minimum amount Ca1PERS, 0118I.0001/706162.2 5 insurance, 2018, contribution only whichever or 1 family - cost up up up cost cost by up cost cost plan to shall to - to of - to of is of is up of is is of is up of is the to to Employee or less cost cost of of insurance, insurance, only 1 family - — up or less up cost to - to whichever $1,135/month whichever up of $715/rnonth to insurance, Employee $715/month insurance, less Employee $1,109/month insurance, less Employee or less + whichevei + — or or - cost Employee $1,460/month whichever + is Employee $1,421/month insurance, less For receive contribution, minimum amount Ca1PERS, Employee $715/month insurance, less Employee $1,135/month insurance, less Employee $1,460/month less + MBFFA as only whichever whichever a required cafeteria or 1— including follows: + whichever + or family or whichevei 14., Dental/Life & See existing language and 2020 and 2021 rates are shown as 14.3 Vision rates from 2017 below. updated MOU language below. Insurance 14., Health Benefits The provisions of this The provisions of this Article shall 14.4 ARTICLE binding through. this term will be MOU, of the effective on the shall the and remainder MOU, parties for be upon the which of be the the effective approval. herewith binding remainder tern of upon to The on the re -open the of City parties MOU, this parties MOU agree which through and will for be Council discussion 01181.0001/706162.2 6 City The to respect for 2019 rates. ie-open any Council parties and to changes this 2020 discussion agiee approval. ARTICLE health to herewith the with with any rates. respect changes to to this the Article, 2022 for health 16.1 16., Salaries shall increase for of July two provide all 1, in Unit percent to 2017, the base a the Salary Reduction End Date The the Living the period base as to a Effective CITY COLA salaries classifications amount (2%). reduction represented implemented The Side No. day successor original 21 agreed during already salary successor 5% and parties December reference to salary occurred, for a effective MOU MOU ceased employees adopted salary period being Year through Association tables the 31 which with attached Exhibit by the for the the 2020. state 5% the to Resolution end Year The attached parties' FY parties has employees their salary current of the to MOU. of A. 2020- updated 85-20 on Letter this table shall that as reduction COLA Two Association shall Adjustment salary including salary Exhibit Lump receive effective schedule Sum B July to represented increase the Payment a 5% 1, Cost be payroll the successor 2021. to Two In overall COVID-19 contingent following conditions, one-time all with the December the recognition members penod financial the sacrifices lump City financial 31 health upon the October of of 2020 CITY sum satisfaction the MBFFA made emergency, Mono 3, terms equal (duration financial shall 2020 during Bay and to employed provide through $500 of during of and the the of concessions by 01 1 81.0001 /706162.2 7 MBFFA) and who is still employed when the lump -sum payments are issued by the City (anticipated to be around October 1, 2021): A. Total of three major General Fund Revenues (Property Tax, Sales Tax and Transient Occupancy Tax) meet or exceed the combined Fiscal Year 2020/21 forecasted amount of $7,757,301 adopted by Council on June 23, 2020 This figure shall be based on curl ent tax rates (curl ently 1 % Property Tax 1.0% CITY Sales Tax, 10% TOT). In the event of increased tax sates, such increased rates would not count towards increased revenue receipts for this purpose. Sales tax shall exclude any consideration of Measure Q, Measure E and Cannabis Tax that that is collected at any time during Fiscal Year 2020-21. B. The CITY does not become responsible for any state / federally imposed unfunded mandates from any external souice(s) that require significant unplanned/un-forecasted General Fund expenditure(s) of more than $125,000 above the projected use of General Fund unassigned Reserves equal to $1,248,000 in the Adopted FY 2020-21 budget (page A-11). This shall include but is not be limited to significant natural disaster(s), worsening financial conditions related to the COVID-19 pandemic or a human - made disaster affecting the CITY. Any such expenditure(s) cumulatively totaling $125,000 in a fiscal year or more, will be 01181.0001/706162.2 8 counted combined discussed the resulting sum C. different pre sum agrees difference This the payment SEIU MBFFA MOU payment payment solely provision of to in members. financial re provided POA as revenue in conditions no SEIU -open in of this on financial a being then the members. one-time for shall the section reduction or the lump amount triggers their are City triggers. lump sum lump apply on to negotiate of based, or which the in - to to the -conditions various Should amount awarded POA not successor either the issue 16., 16.5-7 Salaries 2018-2019 COLAs Delete 21 Layoffs The the forth CITY's along Layoff layoff parties in with Policy. 2.32.120 Municipal procedure the agree CITY of to Code use the as set The procedure of the the City parties CITY's s agree as Personnel set Municipal forth to use Rules. in the 2.32 Code layoff 120 and A FY Schedule 20/21 Salary FY 17/18 Salary Schedule Update schedule for COLA represented FY for 2021-22 MOU and the employee. with with fiscal effectuating salary current year schedule for salary a 5% Exh. each 14.3 Existing Language Life Insurance is provided at $50,000 per employee. The following rates were effective January 1, 2017: Vision Dental Life Totals City pays EE pays Employee only $8.86 $55 47 $8.15 $72 48 $69.50 $2.93 Employee+ 1 $16.59 $143.09 $8.15 $167.83 $156.08 $11.75 Employee+2+ $22.59 $143.09 $8.15 $173.83 $ 161.62 $12.21 01181.0001/706162.2 9 14,3 Proposed Replacement Language Life Insurance is provided at $50,000 per employee. The following rates were effective January I, 2020 and continue through June 30, 2022 unless other renegotiated between the parties by means of a re -opener: Vision Dental Life Totals City pays EE pays Employee only $8,73 $56,68 $8.70 $74.11 $71.18 $2.93 Employee + 1 $16.40 $15 6. 84 $8.70 $ 181.94 $170.19 $11.75 Employee + 2+ $23.34 $156.84 $8.70 $188.88 $176.67 $12.21 This Tentative Agreement is dated April 12, 2021 and shall be effective only upon adoption by the City Council of the City of Morro Bay. Subject to the foregoing, this Tentative Agreement is hereby executed by the authorized representatives of the City and the Association. City of Morro Bay Scot `olli is, City Manager �,- �S- Darla Swanson, City Clerlc/HR Mngr, CA: 100)40,4401 Colin J. Tanner, Deputy City Attorney 01 181.0001 /706162.2 10 Morro Bay Firefighter Assn, IAFF LOCAL 37 Michael Hoese EXHIBIT A CITY OF MORRO BAY FY 20/21 MBFFA SALARY SCHEDULE TITLE STEP 1 STEP 2 STEP 3 STEP 4 STEP 5 FIREFIGHTER 59,065 62,018 65,119 68,375 71,794 FIRE ENGINEER 64,573 67,802 71,192 74,751 78,489 FIRE CAPTAIN 74,227 77,938 81,835 85,927 90,223 FIRE MARSHAL 88,114 92,520 97,146 102,003 107,103 01181.0001/706162.2 11 F,XHIB IT B CITY OF MORRO BAY FY 21/22 MBFFA SALARY SCHEDULE TITLE STEP 1 STEP 2 STEP 3 STEP 4 STEP 5 FIREFIGHTER 62,018 65,119 68,375 71,794 75,384 FIRE ENGINEER 67,802 71,192 74,751 78,489 82,413 FIRE CAPTAIN 77,938 81,835 85,927 90,223 94,735 FIRE MARSHAL 92,520 97,146 102,003 107,103 112,458 Oi I81,0001/706162.2 12 MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE MORRO BAY FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, IAFF LOCAL 3725 AND THE CITY OF MORRO BAY JULY 1, 2020 - JUNE 30, 2022 01181.0026/708071.4 Table of Contents ARTICLE 1 PURPOSE 1 ARTICLE 2 MANAGEMENT 1 ARTICLE 3 MBFFA RECOGNITION 3 ARTICLE 4 MBFFA BUSINESS 4 ARTICLE 5 AUTHORIZED AGENTS 5 ARTICLE 6 WITHHOLDING OF MBFFA DUES AND INSURANCE 5 ARTICLE 7 TERM 6 ARTICLE 8 RENEGOTIATIONS 6 ARTICLE 9 ANTI -DISCRIMINATION 6 ARTICLE 10 WORK SCHEDULE (FOR FIRE MARSHAL, SEE ARTICLE 29) 6 ARTICLE 11 VACATIONS AND HOLIDAYS 8 ARTICLE 12 SICK LEAVE 9 ARTICLE 13 RETIREMENT BENEFITS 10 ARTICLE 14 HEALTH BENEFITS 11 ARTICLE 15 UNIFORM ALLOWANCE 12 ARTICLE 16 SALARIES 13 ARTICLE 17 SPECIAL PAY PRACTICES 16 ARTICLE 18 HEALTH AND SAFETY ARTICLE 18 ARTICLE 19 MINIMUM STAFFING 19 ARTICLE 20 PERSONNEL RULES 19 ARTICLE 21 LAYOFFS 20 ARTICLE 22 PROCESSING OF FORMAL GRIEVANCES 20 ARTICLE 23 ELIMINATION OF FIRE SERVICE 21 ARTICLE 24 NO STRIKE, NO LOCK -OUT 21 ARTICLE 25 FULL UNDERSTANDING, MODIFICATION, WAIVER 21 ARTICLE 26 SEVERABILITY 22 ARTICLE 27 JOINT DRAFTING 21 ARTICLE 28 CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL .21 ARTICLE 29 WORK SCHEDULE AND LEAVE PROVISIONS SPECIFIC TO THE POSITION OF FIRE MARSHAL 22 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE MORRO BAY FIRE FIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, IAFF LOCAL 3725 AND THE CITY OF MORRO BAY 2020 - 2022 ARTICLE I PURPOSE WHEREAS, the City of Morro Bay is a municipal corporation, existing under the laws of the State of California as a general law city (hereinafter referred to as the "CITY") and WHEREAS, the CITY is limited, insofar as funds are concerned, because of a fixed tax rate, and in structure because it is a public entity, rather than a profit -making business; and WHEREAS, the Morro Bay Fire Fighters Association (hereinafter referred to as the "MBFFA") is an unincorporated association under the laws of the State of California, and is affiliated with the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) as IAFF Local 3725; and WHEREAS, the CITY and the MBFFA recognize that the mission and the purpose of the CITY are to provide high -quality and economical municipal services and facilities to the residents of the City of Morro Bay; and WHEREAS, the prior Memorandum of Understanding between the CITY and MBFFA, which was approved September 26 2017 pursuant to Resolution No. 52-17 and covered the period of July 1, 2017 through June 30, 2020 (MBFFA MOU 2017-20), expired by its own terms on June 30, 2020; and WHEREAS, the CITY and MBFFA entered into a temporary side letter agreement, which was adopted by the City Council on September 24, 2020 by Resolution No. 85-20, whereby MBFFA agreed to a five percent (5%) salary reduction for all MBFFA represented employees from October 3, 2020 until a tentative agreement was reached on a successor MOU; and WHEREAS, the CITY and MBFFA now desire to enter into a successor MOU to the MBFFA MOU 2017-2020. THEREFORE, this Memorandum of Understanding (hereinafter referred to as the "MOU") is entered into as of July 1, 2020, between the CITY and the MBFFA. It is the intent and purpose of this MOU to assure sound and mutually -beneficial working and economic relations and conditions between the parties hereto to provide for an orderly and peaceable method and manner of resolving any differences, which may arise, and to negotiate any misunderstanding which could arise, and to set forth, herein, the basic and frill agreement between the parties, concerning the pay, wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment. ARTICLE 2 MANAGEMENT 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 2,1 In order to ensure that the CITY shall continue to carry out its public safety functions, programs and responsibilities to the public, imposed by law, and to maintain efficient public safety service for the citizens of Morro Bay, the CITY continues to reserve an.d retain solely and exclusively all management rights, regardless of the frequency of use including those rights and responsibilities set forth by law, and those CITY rights set forth in the CITY's Personnel Rules and Regulations and including, but not limited to, the following: 2.1.1 To manage the Fire Department, and determine policies and procedures and the light to manage the affairs of the Department. 2.1,2 To determine the existence, or nonexistence, of facts which are the basis of the management decision, in compliance with State law. 2.1.3 To determine the necessity, organization, implementation, and termination of any service or activity conducted by the CITY or other govermnent jurisdiction and to expand or diminish fire services. 2.1.4 To direct, supervise, recruit, select, hire, evaluate, promote, transfer, discipline, discharge, terminate, demote, reduce, suspend, reprimand, withhold salary increases and benefits for disciplinary reasons, or otherwise discipline employees, in accordance with Department or CITY Rules, Regulations, or Ordinances. 2.1.5 To determine the nature, manner, means, extent, type, time, quantity, quality, technology, standard, and level of fire services to be provided to the public. 2,1.6 To require performance of other public safety services not specifically stated herein, in the event of emergency or disaster, as deemed necessary by the CITY. 2.1.7 To lay off employees of the Fire Department because of lack of work or funds or under conditions where continued work would be inefficient or nonproductive or not cost effective, as determined by the CITY, 2.1.8 To determine and/or change the fire facilities, methods, technology, equipment, operations to be performed, organization structure, and allocate or assign work by which the CITY fire operations and services ate to be conducted. 2.1.9 To determine method of financing. 2.1.10 To plan, determine, and manage Department's budget, which includes, but is not limited to changes in the number of locations and types of operations, processes, and materials to be used in carrying out all Fire Department functions and the right to contract or subcontract any work or operations of the Fire Department. 2.1.11 To determine the size and composition of the Fire Department work force, assign work to employees of the Fire Department, in accordance with requirements determined by the Fire Department, and to establish and require compliance to 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU work hours and changes to work hours, work schedules, including call back, standby, and overtime, and other work assignments, except as otherwise limited by this MOU, or subsequent MOUs. 2.1.12 To establish and modify goals and objectives related to productivity and performance programs and standards, including, but not limited to, quality and quantity, and required compliance therewith. 2.1.13 To determine qualifications, skills, abilities, knowledge, selection procedures and standards, job classification, job specifications, and to reallocate and reclassify employees, in accordance with division and/or CITY Rules and Regulations. 2.1.14 To determine the issues of public policy, and the overall goals and objectives of the Fire Department, and to take necessary action to achieve the goals and objectives of the Fire Department 2.1.15 To hire, transfer (intra- or inter- Department), promote, reduce in rank, demote, reallocate, terminate and take other personnel action for non -disciplinary reasons, in accordance with Department and/or CITY Rules, Regulations and Ordinances. 2.1.16 To determine policies, procedures and standards for recruiting, selecting, training, and promoting employees. 2.1.17 To establish, implement, and/or modify rules and regulations, policies, and procedures, related to productivity, performance, efficiency, personal appearance standards, code of ethics and conduct, safety, health, and order, and to require compliance therewith 2.1.18 To maintain order and efficiency in Fire facilities and operation. 2.1.19 To restrict the activity of an employee organization on CITY facilities, except as set forth in this MOU. 2.1.20 To take any, and all, necessary steps and actions to carry out the service requirements and mission of the CITY in emergencies or any other time deemed necessary by the CITY, and not specified above 2.2 Nothing herein is meant to diminish CITY rights provided by the Government Code. 2.3 Nothing herein is meant to diminish employee rights as provided by the Government Code, including the right to meet and confer on changes in standards for promotion ARTICLE 3 MBFFA RECOGNITION 3.1 Pursuant to Resolution No. 08-17, the Employer -Employee Relations Resolution of the City of Mono Bay and applicable state law, the MBFFA was designated by the CITY as 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU the representative of CITY fire fighting employees. The term "employee" or employees" as used herein is comprised of the following classifications: Captain/Paramedic Captain Engineer/Paramedic Engineer Fire Marshal Firefighter/Paramedic Firefighter 3.2 Employees working on a regular basis in a classified position, but less than full -tune, shall receive vacation and sick leave accruals on a pio-rated basis, commensurate with hours worked. All benefits for new hires, including insurance benefits, will be allocated on a pro -rated basis commensurate with hours worked. 3.3 FIRE ENGINEER RATING 3,3.1 It is recognized, in principle, as long as the fitll-time MBFFA personnel complement of the Moiro Bay Fire Department remains at ten (10) or less, that efficient operation of the Department requires an increase in the authorized number of Fire Engineers. Accordingly, CITY agrees to promote to Fire Engineer all personnel classified as Fire Fighter hired after the effective date of this MOU provided that they have served for eighteen (18) months with the CITY in the Fire Fighter classification; that at the completion of eighteen months of employment, they have been reconunended by the Fire Chief for promotion and have demonstrated, through successful completion of written and practical examinations that they have successfully completed six semester units of Fire Science courses at an institution approved by the Fire Chief. The CITY shall make every effort to schedule the examination to be completed prior to the expiration of eighteen months The content and passing grade of the written and practical examinations will be determined by the Fire Chief subject to the approval of the City Manager. 3.3.2 An individual recommended for promotion, and failing to attain a passing grade in either the written or practical examination, shall not be eligible for reexamination until six (6) months after the date of failure. ARTICLE 4 MBFFA BUSINESS 4.1 Employee representatives, designated by the MBFFA, shall be granted time off without loss of pay, to attend "meet and confer' sessions with the City Manager, and/or their designee(s), on subjects within the scope of representation, when such meetings are scheduled during regular working hours. Should such meeting extend beyond an employee representative's regular working hours, the employee representative shall be paid for only the regular working hours 01181.0026/708071.4Moiro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 4.2 It is understood that this time -off provision shall only apply to a maximum of two employees attending any one meeting between CITY and MBFFA; where exceptional circumstances warrant, the City Manager may approve the attendance, at such meetings of additional employee representatives. The MBFFA shall, whenever practicable, submit the names of all employee representatives to the City Manager, or their designee(s), at least two working days in advance of such meetings. Provided further: 1) no employee representative shall leave his or her duty or work station or assignment without specific approval of the department head or other authorized CITY management official; and 2) any such meeting is subject to scheduling by CITY management, in a manner consistent with operational needs and work schedules 4.3 Off -duty employees will not be paid for attending meet and confer sessions, nor will over -time be paid for same. The pasties agree to consider the shift schedules of team members in scheduling meetings. 4.4 MBFFA may hold unit meetings at the Fire Station, 715 Harbor Street, after 1700 hours, with two days prior notice to Fire Chief. The Fire Chief has the authority to deny and/or cancel said meeting, if it conflicts with official CITY activities for MBFFA duties. 4.5 New Hire Information and Orientation per AB 119. The CITY will notify MBFFA's designated representative in writing or via email regarding all new hires at least ten (10) days prior to the employee's orientation unless there is an urgent need that was not reasonably foreseeable. Within the earlier of thirty (30) days after the date of hire or by the first pay period of the month following the hire of each newly hired employee, the CITY will provide the MBFFA's designated representative with the new employee's name, job title, department work location, home mailing address, personal email, and work, home and personal cell phone numbers The new hire will receive a copy of this MOU with their new employee orientation packet. MBFFA shall be permitted one (1) hour for each orientation session to talk to new Unit members to explain the rights and benefits under this MOU. The CITY will provide MBFFA's designated representative a quarterly list of all employees in the represented bargaining unit including the employee s name, job title, department work location home mailing address, personal email, and work, home and personal cell phone numbers. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the CITY will not provide MBFFA with the home address, home telephone number, personal cellular telephone number, or personal email address or date of birth of any employee who has made a written request to the CITY regarding non -disclosure of said information. The parties will mutually agree on a form to use to track said employee information and whether any employee requests that such information not be disclosed 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU MBFFA shall indemnify and hold harmless the CITY, its officers, agents, and employees fi•om any and all claims, demands, damages, costs, expenses, or liability arising out of this Article. ARTICLE 5 AUTHORIZED AGENTS For the express purpose of administering the terms and provisions of this MOU: 5.1 Management's principal authorized agent shall be the City Manager, or their duly authorized representative(s) (address 595 Harbor Street, Morro Bay, CA 93442; telephone (805) 772-6201), except where a particular management representative is specifically designated in the MOU. 5.2 The MBFFA principal authorized representative shall be the shop steward of the unit, or their duly authorized representative(s) (address 715 Harbor St., Mono Bay CA 93442). ARTICLE 6 WITHHOLDING OF MBFFA DUES AND INSURANCE 6.1 As the recognized majority and/or exclusive employee organization, the MBFFA requests that the CITY deduct membership dues, initiation fees, and general assessments, as well as payment of any other membership benefit program sponsored by the MBFFA, from the wages and salaries of members of the MBFFA. The MBFFA hereby certifies that it has and shall maintain all such deduction authorizations signed by the individual from whose salary or wages the deduction is to be made and shall not be required to provide a copy of an individual authorization to the CITY unless a dispute arises about the existence or terms of the authorization. The MBFFA membership dues shall be deducted each pay period in accordance with CITY procedures and provisions of applicable law from the salary of each employee whose name is provided by the MBFFA. CITY does not accept responsibility for computing the amounts of deductions or for meeting payment dates, which may not coincide with established pay periods. CITY will issue a single check to the MBFFA for the total amount of deductions withheld from the individual employees pay The MBFFA will be responsible for the accounting and disbursing of all such funds received from CITY. MBFFA will be responsible for properly notifying CITY of any changes in deductions, and will be the sole agent, through which CITY will act, in explaining, initiating, executing, or terminating the provisions of this Article. Such notification must be received by the CITY at least two weeks prior to the effective date of the change. Also such change notice must include a copy of the notice sent to the employees officially, telling them of the change. 6.2 MBFFA shall indemnify and hold harmless the CITY, its officers, agents, and employees from any and all claims, demands, damages, costs, expenses, or liability arising out of this Article. 01181.0026/708071.4Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 6.3 It is agreed that CITY will deposit payroll deductions made payable to a CITY -approved Credit Union providing the MBFFA makes arrangements for such services that are acceptable to both members and CITY. ARTICLE 7 TERM Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, the term of this MOU shall be from July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2022. ARTICLE 8 RENEGOTIATIONS 8.1 In the event either party wants to renegotiate a successor MOU, such party shall serve upon the other during the period of December 1, 2021 to January 31, 2022, its written request to begin negotiations, as well as its full and entire written proposals amending this MOU. Negotiations shall commence no later than March 15, 2022. 8.2 The parties agiee that, except by mutual agreement, no new subjects may be introduced into the process after the third (3rd) negotiations meeting. 8.3 Should the parties be unable to reach agreement on a new contract before the current contract expires, all applicable provisions of this MOU shall remain in full force and effect until such time as a new MOU is reached, or September 30, 2022, whichever first occurs. ARTICLE 9 ANTI -DISCRIMINATION The CITY and MBFFA mutually agree they will not discriminate against employees for the exercise of their rights under the State of California Government Code Section 3502. ARTICLE 10 WORK SCHEDULE (FOR FIRE MARSHAL, SEE ARTICLE 29) This article is intended to define the normal hours of work, and shall not be construed as a guarantee of work per day or work per week or of days of work per week. 10.1 WORKDAY The normal workday shall be a twenty-four (24) consecutive hour period except in cases of emergency or for reasons of attendance at extended training opportunities, or temporary duty assignments while on light duty, when other shifts may be assigned by the Chief, provided there is mutual agreement between the parties. 10.2 WORKSHIFT Employees shall be scheduled to work on regular work shifts having regular starting and quitting times. Except for emergencies, employees work shifts shall not be changed without four days (96 hours) prior written notice to the employee. Call out or overtime does not constitute a change in work shift. 10.3 WORKWEEK 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 20221VJOU The normal workweek shall average fifty-six (56) hours of work in a seven (7) consecutive day period except in cases of emergency. 10.4 OVFRTIMF 10.4.1 Overtime is defined as all hours worked in excess of 106 hours worked in a 14- day work period. For those assigned to an 8-hour day overtime shall be defined as all hours worked in excess of forty hours per week. Vacation time and compensatory time off shall be treated as hours worked. 10.4.2 All overtime, as defined above, shall be paid at one and one-half (1.5) times the employee's regular late of pay. Compensatory time off earned pursuant to 10.4.4 below, will accrue at one and one-half (1.5) times hours worked. 10.4.3 Employees, required to return to work on a scheduled vacation day, shall be paid at the rate of 1.5 times their regular rate of pay for the hours actually worked 10.4.4 Employees may elect compensatory time off (CTO) in lieu of paid overtime, subject to the following provisions. 10.4.4,1 CTO may be elected for overtime incurred due to training time only. 10.4.4.2 Maximum CTO accrual will be 140 hours All overtime earned after CTO is accrued to the 140-hour maximum will be paid in cash. 10.4.4.3 Accrued CTO may be cashed out upon the request of the employee and the approval of the department. CTO accrued at time of separation will be paid off. 10.4.4.4 CTO may be taken off upon employee request and department approval. CTO will not be approved if it will require overtime. 10.4.4.5 Other overtime provisions notwithstanding, employees forced to hold over for 12 hours or more will receive time and one-half compensation for the hours worked on that day. 10.5 EMERGENCIES 10.5.1 Nothing herein shall be construed to limit or restrict the authority of management to make temporary assignments to different or additional locations, shifts, or duties for the purpose of meeting an emergency. 10.5.2 Such emergency assignments shall not extend beyond the period of said emergency. 10.5.3 Short —staffing, caused solely by absences due to employees taking approved paid leave, shall not be considered an emergency. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 ?vIOU ARTICLE 11 VACATIONS AND HOLIDAYS 11.1 CITY and MBFFA agree that difficulties exist in equating the work schedules of fire fighters to the work schedule of non -shift personnel, i.e., shift periods compared to hours and days worked by other CITY employees. Therefore, a formula is agreed to for computing the vacations and holiday periods for file fighters. Such formula is agreed to be a ratio as follows: Fire Fighter's total available shifts per year is to the general employees' total available woilc days pei year (260) as X is to the numbei of authorized vacation and holidays days of the general employees, when X equals the amount of shifts off for Fire Fighters comparing File Fighters to employees of equal tenure 11.2 Pursuant to Section 11.1, the following lists the vacation and holiday annual accrual schedule for members of the MBFFA assigned to shift work: SERVICE VACATION HOLIDAY TOTAL ANNUAL SHIFTS/ YEARS ACCRUAL ACCRUAL ENTITLEMENT YEAR 0 thru 2 3 thru 4 5 thru 6 7 thiu 8 9 thru 10 11 thru 12 13 thru 14 15 thru 16 17 that 18 19 thru 20 21+ 112.0 hrs. 123.2 hrs. 134.4 hrs. 145.6 hrs. 156.8 hrs. 168.0 hrs. 179.2 hrs 190.4 hrs 201.6 hrs. 212.8 hrs 224.0 hrs. 11.3 MAXIMUM ACCUMULATION 146,96 hrs. 146.96 hrs. 146.96 hrs. 146.96 hrs 146.96 hrs 146.96 his 146.96 hrs. 146.96 hrs 146.96 hrs 146.96 hrs. 146.96 hrs 258.96 hrs. 270.16 hrs. 281.36 hrs. 292.52 hrs. 303.76 hrs. 314.96 hrs. 326.16 hrs. 337.36 hrs. 348.56 hrs 359.76 hrs. 370.96 hrs. 10.792 11.257 11,723 12.19 12.657 13.123 13.59 14.057 14.523 14.99 15.547 It is recognized long-standing accumulations of vacation/holiday time exist foi some employees. In ordei to compensate employees for this unused time CITY and MBFFA agree on the following policy: 11.3.1 Unused vacation/holiday leave may be carried over into the following year to a maximum of two times an employee's annual accumulation of vacation time plus one year of holiday time. Employees exceeding the maximum, as of the pay period containing November 1 of each year, will be paid off for time exceeding the maximum. The CITY shall make said payment with the pay period containing December 1 of each year. Payment shall be computed, based upon the employee's base hourly rate of pay as of June 30 of the same calendar year. 11.3.2 Employees separating from the CITY are entitled to pay for the accumulated vacation based upon employee's base hourly rate of pay at separation. 01 J81.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 11.3.3 A member of the MBFFA may exercise an option to convert into cash a maximum of one hundred twelve (112) hours of accrued vacation leave each fiscal year. Such conversion shall be computed at the employee's current base hourly rate, on an hour -per -hour basis 11,4 The following holidays are used in Section 11.2 above, to determine total annual entitlement. Employees may be scheduled to work on holidays. All employees, except those assigned to 8-hour shifts, shall be compensated foi holidays as piovided in 11 2 above. New Year's Day Martin Luther King, Jr., Day Lincoln's Birthday President's Day Memorial Day Independence Day Labor Day Veteran's Day Thanksgiving Day Day after Thanksgiving Day Christmas Day Floating Holiday Floating Holiday January 1 3" Monday in January February 12 3'd Monday in February Last Monday in May July 4 1$' Monday in September November 11 4" Thursday in November 4"' Friday in November December 25 Varies Varies 11.5 For any additional holiday proclaimed by the Mayor, shift employees shall be paid (not banked) for 11.2 hours of work, and employees assigned to eight -hour duty shall receive the holiday off. Employees may be scheduled to work on such holidays. ARTICLE 12 SICK LEAVE 12.1 It is agreed that the firefighters will earn sick leave per month at the same ratio that their assigned shift schedule compares to other full-time employees (1.4:1) for 24-hour shift workers or (1.0:1) for eight -hour shift employees. There shall be no maximum number of sick leave hours that a member of MBFFA may accrue. 12,2 All use of sick leave shall be charged on an hour -for -hour basis. 12.3 At termination, accumulated in the sick leave accrual is not compensable; however, upon retirement, sick leave accrual may be converted to additional time as provided by California Public Employees Retirement System (Ca1PERS) unused sick leave credit. 12.4 Any use of sick leave, covering a period beyond seven calendar days, may require approval by a qualified medical authority for release to resume regular duties. 01181.0026/708071.41vtorro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 12.5 Recognizing Section 12.1 above requires a transition from the method of accruing and charging sick leave contained in earlier Memoranda of Understanding, the following conversion of previously accrued sick leave shall be made: 12.5.1 For shift workers, all Sick Leave hours accrued, but unused, as of December 31, 2002 shall be multiplied by a factor of three (3) and shall become the employee's Sick Leave Accrual account, until utilized on an hour for hour basis. 12.5.2 Credits added to the Sick Leave Accrual account for full-time employees, after the date above, shall be 11.2 hours per month, or 0.046154 hours, for each regular hour worked for part-time employees on shift work or eight (8) hours per month for employees assigned to an eight -hour day. Effective upon City Council approval of this MOU until December 31, 2021 sick leave accrual credits shall be increased by 2 hours credit per month foi full-time employees. 12.6 Based on individual utilization of paid sick leave in the preceding calendar year, employee may convert unused accumulated sick leave into paid vacation leave once per calendar year, pursuant to the formula below: Maximum Conversion Sick Leave Utilization 0 hours .25 to 8 hours 8.25 to 16 hours 16 25 to 25 hours Over 25 hours Sick Leave 96 hours 72 hours 48 hours 24 hours 0 hours To Vacation Leave 48 hours 36 hours 24 hours 12 hours 0 hours At least 160 accrued hours must remain in employee's sick leave bank for any employee to be eligible for conversion, or for any conversion to be authorized. In addition, the right to convert does not carry over or rollover from calendar year to calendar year; failure to request conversion, in the current calendar year eliminates the right to do so for that calendar year, and does not permit employees to aggregate conversion hours in any other calendar year. ARTICLE 13 RETIREMENT BENEFITS 13.1 It is the employee s obligation to contribute the employee's contribution to Ca1PERS. The employee shall pay their own contribution by payroll deduction consistent with the provisions of 414 (h) 2 of the Internal Revenue Code (9% Ca1PERS Safety for classic members; 50% of the expected normal cost, which is currently 23% (employee pays 11.5%), for new members). 13.2 The CITY agrees to continue to provide MBFFA, hired prior to March 19, 2011, with a retirement benefit program through the Ca1PERS as follows: 13.2.1 3% @ 50 formula (Section 21362.2) 01181,0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 13 2 2 Unused Sick Leave Credit (Section 20965) 13.2.3 Military Service Credit (Section 21023 5, 21024 & 21027) 13,2.4 Final Compensation 1 year (Section 20042) 13.2.5 1959 Survivor Benefit Level 4 (Section 21574) 13.2.6 Pre -Retirement Death Benefits (Section 21548 Option 2W & 21551) 13.2.7 Retired Death Benefit $500 (Section 21620) 13.2.8 Prior Service (Section 20055) 13.2.9 Public Service Credit foi Periods of Layoff (Section 21022) 13.3 All employees, hired on or after March 19, 2011, but before January 1, 2013 and those hired on or after January 1, 2013, who meet the definition of classic member, pursuant to the California Public Employee's Pension Reform Act of 2013 (PF,PRA), in the regular, fill -time classifications listed in Article 3.1 of this MOU between the CITY and the MBFFA, shall be provided with the following Ca1PERS retirement benefits: 13.3.1 3% a, 55 formula (Section 21363.1) 13.3.2 Unused Sick Leave Credit (Section 20965) 13.3.3 Military Service Credit (Section 21023.5, 21024 & 21027) 13.3.4 Final compensation 3 Year (Section 20037) 13.3.5 1959 Survivor Benefit Level 4 (Section 21574) 13.3.6 Pre -Retirement Death Benefits (Section 21548 Option 2W & 21551) 13.3.7 Retired Death Benefit $500 (Section 21620) 13.3.8 Prior Service (Section 20055) 13.3.9 Public Service Credit for Periods of Layoff (Section 21022) 13.4 Pursuant to the California Public Employees' Pension Reform Act of 2013 (PFPRA), effective January 1, 2013, Sworn employees hired, who meet the definition of new member under PEPRA and are not eligible for reciprocity, will be provided the following Ca1PhRS benefits: 13.4.1 2.7% c 57 formula (Section 7522 25(d)) 13.4.2 Unused Sick Leave Credit (Section 20965) 13.4.3 Military Service Credit (Sections 21023.5, 21024 & 21027) 13.4.4 Final compensation 3 Year (Section 20037) 13.4.5 1959 Survivor Benefit Level (Section 21574) 13.4.6 Pre -Retirement Death Benefits (Section 21548 Option 2W and 21551) 13.4.7 Retired Death Benefit $500 (Section 21620) 13.4,8 Prior Service (Section 20055) 13.4.9 Public Service Credit foi Periods of Layoff (Section 21022) 13.5 CITY and MBFFA to jointly explore the establishment of an employee -funded Retirement Health Savings Account. ARTICLE 14 HEALTH BENEFITS 01181.0026/708071.4 Marra Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 14.1 CITY shall pay, to each active employee by each pay period, the monthly sum of the health plan selected by the employee, and dental/life and vision plans. CITY and MBFFA agree that CITY payment of this lump sum is to be used to provide medical care coverage for the employee and/or employees dependents, and that the employees hold harmless the CITY, its officers and agents, including but not limited to, liability arising out of this MOU. Employees will be supplied with the current division of payment for medical, dental/life and vision insurance between CITY and each employee in MBFFA, as changes occur during this MOU. 14.2 HEALTH INSURANCE For 2020 and 2021, MBFFA shall receive a cafeteria plan contribution, including the minimum contribution amount required by Ca1PERS, as follows: Employee only - up to $715/month or cost of insurance, whichever is less Employee + 1— up to $1 135/month or cost of insurance, whichever is less Employee + family - up to $1,460/month or cost of insurance, whichever is less 14.3 DFNTAL/LIFE AND VISION INSURANCE Life Insurance is provided at $50,000 per employee. The following rates were effective January 1, 2020 and continue through June 30, 2022 unless other renegotiated between the parties by means of a re -opener: Employee only Employee + 1 Employee + 2+ Vision $ 8.73 $ 16.40 $ 23.34 Dental $ 56.68 $156.84 $156.84 Life $8.70 $8.70 $8.70 Totals $ 74.11 $ 181.94 $ 188.88 City pays $ 71.18 $ 170.19 $ 176.67 RF pays $ 293 $11.75 $12.21 CITY will pay the remaining premium for dental, life and vision. 14.4 The provisions of this ARTICLE shall be binding on the parties through the remainder of the term of this MOU, which will be effective upon City Council approval. The parties agree herewith to re -open discussion with respect to this ARTICLE, for any changes to the 2022 health rates. ARTICLE 15 UNIFORM ALLOWANCE The uniform for the Fire Department is a two-piece work uniform and two T-shirts, of a style, material and manufacture determined by the Fire Chief Two (2) complete uniforms will be provided upon initial employment with the Fire Department, and replacements provided are on an "as needed basis,' as determined by the Fire Chief. The CITY will provide safety footgear of a type style, and manufacture, as recommended by the Fire Chief. CITY is responsible for normal upkeep, i.e., heels and soles, with replacement as determined by the Fire Chief 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU ARTICLE 16 SALARIES 16,1 The base salaries in effect as of June 30 2020 through October 2, 2020 and effective January 1, 2021 shall be as shown in Exhibit A. (The CITY and MBFFA agreed through a side letter to a five percent (5%) salary reduction for Unit members for the period of October 3, 2020 through December 31, 2020.) Effective July 1, 2021, the CITY shall provide a cost of living adjustment ( `COLA") inciease to base salaries foi all Unit classifications in the amount of five percent (5%), as shown in Exhibit B. 16.2 Any and all education/ special pay incentives will be added to base salary. 16.3 Electronic Deposit. All employees hired after January 1, 2003, shall receive their pay by electronic methods. New hires must present account information for a checking or a savings account, with an ACH member financial institution 16.4 Lump Sum Payment Year Two In recognition of the financial and overall sacrifices made during the COVID-19 health emergency contingent upon satisfaction of the following financial terms and conditions, the CITY will provide a one-time lump sum equal to $500 to all Unit members employed with the CITY during the period October 3, 2020 through December 31, 2020 (dutation of the financial concessions by MBFFA) and who ate still employed when the lump -sum payments are issued by the CITY (anticipated to be around October 1, 2021) A, Total of three major General Fund Revenues (Property Tax, Sales Tax and Transient Occupancy Tax) meet or exceed the combined Fiscal Year 2020/21 forecasted amount of $7,757,301 adopted by Council on June 23, 2020. This figure shall be based on current tax rates (currently 1% Property Tax, 1,0% CITY Sales Tax 10% TOT). In the event of increased tax rates, such increased rates would not count towards increased revenue receipts foi this purpose. Sales tax shall exclude any consideration of Measure Q, Measure E and Cannabis Tax that that is collected at any time during Fiscal Year 2020-21. B. The CITY does not become responsible for any state / federally imposed unfunded mandates from any external sour ce(s) that require significant unplanned/un-forecasted General Fund expenditure(s) of more than $125,000 above the projected use of General Fund unassigned Reserves equal to $1,248,000 rn the Adopted FY 2020-21 budget (page A-11). This shall include but is not limited to significant natural disaster(s), worsening financial conditions related to the COVID-19 pandemic or a human -made disaster affecting the CITY, Any such expenditure(s), cumulatively totaling $125,000 in a fiscal year or more, will be counted as a reduction in the combined revenue amount discussed in this section on which the various conditions are based, resulting in no one-time lump - sum payment being awarded to Unit members. C. Should SEIU or POA negotiate different financial triggers or pre -conditions for their lump sum payment, then the CITY agrees to re -open this MOU solely on the 01181.0026/708071.4Mom) Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 k[OU issue of the difference in financial triggers. This provision shall not apply to the amount of the lump sum payment provided either to SEIU or POA members. ARTICLE 17 SPECIAL PAY PRACTICES 17.1 MFDIC DIFFERENTIAL 17.1.1 An employee, certified as an FMT-P (Paramedic), shall receive an annual incentive of $6,088 68. This incentive is calculated as 9% of a Step 5 firefightei's salary ($67 652 x 9%). The incentive will be paid on a bi-weekly payroll in the amount of $234.18. 17.1.2 The CITY may require any employee to attend EMT-P training. 17.2 CALL -OUT PAY 17.2,1 It is agreed that the CITY will guarantee a minimum of three (3) hours pay, computed at straight hourly rates, for any MBFFA member called back to duty from an off -duty status. 17.2.2 If an employee is called to return to duty, such call -out shall not be canceled until the employee reports to the Fire Station. To be eligible to receive the minimum the employee must report to the Fire Station. 17.2.3 If an employee is on -duty and held beyond the end of the work period, time worked will be paid as actual hours worked, under Section 10.4 of this MOU. Such holdover shall not qualify for Call -out Pay. 17.3 WORKING OUT -OF -CLASS Employees may be worked on an out -of -class assignment only as provided in the Personnel Rules and Regulations of the CITY, except as provided herein below: 17.3.1 Employees shall receive an additional 5% compensation for out -of -class assignments that last 24 consecutive hours. Such additional 5% pay shall start on the 25th hour, retroactive to the first hour of the out -of -class assignment. Such additional compensation shall be paid during the first six (6) months of the out -of - class assignment. 17.3.2 If the assignment is extended by six (6) months, then starting on the first day of the extension: 17.3.2.1 The employee shall continue to receive the 5% compensation, if the out -of -class assignment is required to fill an absence due to an employee who is out on 4850 leave. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 17.3.2,2 The employee shall receive an additional 5% for a total of 10% additional compensation, if the out -of -class assignment is required to fill a vacant position. 17,3.3 An employee placed in an out -of -class assignment will not be taken off that assignment for the sole purpose of avoiding the payment provided above, 17.3.4 Whenever possible, CITY intends to fill vacancies with qualified employees. 17.3,5 Short-term out -of -class assignments (such as acting captain) will be paid on an hour -for -hour basis. 17.4 STANDBY PAY Compensation for standby duty for acting Fine Chief position, when not called back to duty, shall be paid two (2) hours of overtime pay (acting rate) per full 24-hour shift. 17,5 SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT PAY 17.5.1 Unit members, possessing the appropriate certification as determined by the City, and assigned to work as part of the Rescue Water Craft program operating specialized equipment, shall receive additional compensation of two percent (2%) of base pay. This incentive is limited to a maximum of six (6) designated employees, starting upon approval of this MOU, but may be expanded to eight (8) designated employees, upon approval of City Manager and City Council approval of the additional budgeted funds, City makes no representations as to whether this special pay may be included in a Unit member's ` compensation earnable" for purposes of determining the Unit member's Ca1PERS retirement allowance. 17.5.2 Unit members, possessing the appropriate certification as determined by the City, and assigned to work as pait of the San Luis Obispo County Hazardous Materials Team shall receive additional compensation of two percent (2%) of base pay. This incentive is limited to a maximum of two (2) designated employees, stalling upon approval of this MOU. ARTICLE 18 HEALTH AND SAFETY ARTICLE 18.1 Management shall provide and maintain safe and healthy work facilities and equipment. 18.2 Safety and health conditions in employment in the CITY are subject to the provisions of State and Federal legislation, which regulates the health environment and safety conditions of the work place. 18.3 A Citywide Safety/Loss Control Committee shall be established, and shall review accidents, review alleged safety deficiencies, and recommend safety training and safety equipment. The MBFFA may appoint one Unit representative to serve on the committee. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 ]IOU If the committee meets, during the designated employee's normal working hours, the employee shall receive paid release time to attend the meeting. 18.4 If an employee becomes alerted to an unsafe condition or health hazard, they shall report such condition to their immediate supervisor. If such conditions cannot be satisfactorily remedied by the immediate supervisor, an employee has the right to submit the matter either personally, or through the steward, to their Department Head, or designated safety representative. On any matter of safety not resolved after proceeding through the above process, consultation will take place between management and the MBFFA, if requested. 18.5 A first aid kit shall be furnished and maintained at work facilities readily and conveniently accessible to MBFFA employees. 18.6 Management agrees to provide to employees, who are exposed to potentially toxic agents or toxic materials, the appropriate medical services at no cost to the employee. 18.7 Any safety equipment required by the CITY shall be furnished by the CITY. ARTICLE 19 MINIMUM STAFFING 19.1 CITY agrees to provide minimum staffing of three full-time personnel except in cases of emergency as determined by the Fire Chief. a. Exception: For brief transitional periods lasting 10 hours or less, minimum staffing may be allowed to drop to a minimum of two with the Chiefs approval. 19.2 Prior City Strategic Plans have recommended the CITY provide 4-person daily staffing in the Fire Department a. The CITY and MBFFA agree that 4-person full-time minimum staffing will be provided in the MOU when a second fire station or second company is staffed and operational. The 4-person minimum refers to the total on -duty staffing of full-time firefighters in the CITY. The CITY currently staffs a single, two-piece suppression company consisting of an engine and a rescue. This response configuration is not affected by item a. above. 19.3 The CITY agrees to cap the total number of part-time, unrepresented firefighters to one per scheduled 24-hour shift. a Exception: In an emergency, and for mutual aid response coverage, the CITY may have more than one reserve firefighter working 24-hour shifts, provided the CITY is meeting its minimum staffing requirements 19.3.1 The Fire Chief may assign the least senior qualified Engineer as a floater to fill shifts when other Unit members are off on leave, training, or otherwise unable to 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU cover their assigned shifts. There may also be some situations whereby it may be a benefit to both parties wherein the Fire Chief may assign a represented member who may need to flex their schedule as the floater upon the agreement of both the Fire Chief and the member. 19.3.2 The CITY will post a work schedule every 30 days for the vacation relief position and provide 96 hours notice prior to making schedule changes. There will be no mole than two schedule changes within each 30-day schedule. ARTICLE 20 PERSONNEL RULES Parties recognize the applicability and agreement with the Personnel Rules utilized by the CITY for all employees. From time to time the Personnel Rules may be amended and the CITY will offer the opportunity to meet and confer on those items, within the scope of bargaining. Nothing in this article shall make the CITY's Personnel Rules subject to the Grievance Procedure. ARTICLE 21 LAYOFFS The parties agree to use the layoff procedure as set forth in 231120 of the CITY's Municipal Code and the CITY's Personnel Rules. For purposes of workforce reductions, as outlined by the CITY's Personnel Rules and Regulations, shifts worked by part-time unrepresented employees will be eliminated prior to a reduction in full-time MOU-represented personnel. ARTICLE 22 PROCESSING OF FORMAL GRIEVANCES 22.1 The MBFFA agrees that whenever investigation or processing of a grievance is to be transacted during working hours, only the amount of time necessary to bring about a prompt disposition of the matter will be utilized. It is further agreed that the time spent on an investigation and processing of grievances will not interfere with the normal operation of the department. CITY agrees to provide a reasonable amount of time for the investigation and the processing of a grievance, but by so agreeing does not imply that the piocessing or investigation of a grievance shall take priority over normal fiinctions of the department. 22.2 CITY further agrees that any payment of overtime arising because of MBFFA personnel's involvement in grievance investigation or processing shall not be author ized. Time spent on the investigation and processing of grievances will be recorded on a form provided by CITY. Stewards will be permitted reasonable time -off with pay for the investigation and piocessing of grievances provided, however, stewards shall first obtain permission from the department head and/or their designee and inform him/her of the nature of their business. CITY shall giant such permission promptly unless such absence would cause an undue interruption of work or would require the CITY to pay overtime in order to maintain the normal operation of the department. 01181.0026/70807L9Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 22.3 Upon entering the work location, the steward shall inform the department head and supervisor of the nature of their business. Permission to leave a job will be granted to the employee involved unless such absence would cause an interruption of world. If the employee cannot be made available, the steward will seek an alternate time for employee availability with the department head or supervisor. 22.4 It is agreed that in some instances the investigation and processing of a grievance may be accomplished on the employee's time. This MOU is in recognition of the mutual sharing of costs involved in the handling of employee -initiated actions. 22.5 Procedures shall be in accordance with Resolution No. 46-74 and any amendments thereto. ARTICLE 23 ELIMINATION OF FIRE SERVICE If the fire service function of the CITY is merged into another agency, or if another agency assumes said fimction, then prior to such action, the CITY shall meet and confer with MBFFA concerning the effects of such action. ARTICLE 24 NO STRIKE, NO LOCK -OUT 24.1 During the life of this MOU, the CITY will not lock out any employees nor will the MBFFA cause, authorize, advise or encourage any interruption of work or any other concerted refusal to render services or to work, including overtime or any other curtailment or restriction of work at any time during the term of this MOU. The term "interruption of world' shall mean any work stoppage or strike (including economic and unfair labor practice strikes) or any intentional slow down of work. 24.2 There shall be no refusal to work on, handle or produce any materials or equipment because of a labor dispute 24.3 Any employee engaging in any action prohibited by this Article shall be subject to immediate discharge or such other discipline as the CITY may assess. Such discharge or discipline shall not be reviewable through the Grievance Procedure. ARTICLE 25 FULL UNDERSTANDING, MODIFICATION, WAIVER 25.1 This MOU sets forth the full and entire understanding of the parties, regarding the matters set forth herein and any other prior or existing understanding or MOUs by the parties, whether formal or informal regarding any such matters are hereby superseded or terminated in their entirety. 25.2 It is agreed and understood that each party hereto voluntarily and unqualifiedly waives its right to negotiate, and agrees that the other party shall not be required to negotiate, with respect to any matter covered herein. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 25.3 No agreement, alteration understanding, variation, waiver, or modification of any of the terms or provisions contained herein shall in any manner be binding upon the parties hereto unless made and executed in writing by all parties hereto, and if required, approved by the CITY and ratified by the membership of' the MBFFA. 25.4 The waiver of any breach of any term, or condition of this MOU by either party shalt not constitute a precedent in the future enforcement of all its terms and provisions. ARTICLE 26 SEVERABILITY If any provision(s) are held to be contrary to law by a court of competent jurisdiction such provisions will not be deemed valid and subsisting except to the extent permitted by law, but all other provisions will continue in full force and effect. ARTICLE 27 JOINT DRAFTING Each party has cooperated in the drafting and preparation of this MOU. Hence, in any legal construction or interpretation to be made of this MOU, the same shall not be construed against any party. ARTICLE 28 — CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL The CITY 's labor relations representatives and the MBFFA's representatives have met and conferred in good faith on wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment for the unit members represented by the MBFFA and have reached agreements which are set forth in this MOU. This MOU when executed by the CITY's labor relations representatives and the MBFFA s representatives constitutes a joint recommendation therefrom, after ratification of the MBFFA s membership, to be submitted to the City Council for its determination and approval by resolution, as the City Council may deem fit and proper. This Memorandum of Understanding is of no force or effect unless or until approved and adopted by a resolution of the City Council. ARTICLE 29 WORK SCHEDULE AND LEAVE PROVISIONS SPECIFIC TO THE POSITION OF FIRE MARSHAL The foregoing sections in this Article 29 shall apply only to the position of Fire Marshal. The Fire Marshal's work schedule, and entitlement to overtime, compensatory time off, vacation leave, and holiday leave shall only be as provided in this Article 29. 29.1 Work Schedule. 29.1.1. Workday. The normal workday shall be eight hours of work in a 24-consecutive hour period except in cases of emergencies That work schedule may be altered to conduct inspections during special CITY events and is subject to call back for emergencies. In no case shall the Fire Marshal cover 24-hour shifts. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Associal ion 2020 - 2022 MOU 2912. Work Shift. The Fire Marshal shall be scheduled to work on regular work shifts having iegulai starting and quitting times. 29.1.3. Work Week. The normal workweek shall be five workdays and two consecutive days of rest in a seven-day period, beginning Saturday 12:00 a.m., and ending seven days later on Friday night at 11159 p.m., except m cases of special CITY events or emergencies, or at the specific request of the Fire Marshal and approval of the fire chief. 29.1.4. Overtime Compensation. Overtime for the Fire Marshal is defined as all work required by the CITY and actually pei formed beyond 40 hours worked in a workweek, as defined by FLSA, and shall be compensated at one and one-half times the employee's regular rate of pay, as defined by FLSA. The Fire Marshal shall not be eligible for daily over time. Vacation time and compensatory time off shall be treated as hours worked The Fire Marshal shall not be entitled to a premium rate of pay for work on Saturdays, Sundays, holidays, or regular days of rest, provided they do not work beyond 40 hours in a workweek. (For example, if due to a special CITY event, the Fire Marshal works five, eight -hour work days from Wednesday through Sunday, they will not be entitled to any premium rate of pay.) 29.1.5 Compensatory Time. The Fire Marshal shall be eligible to elect for compensatory time off (CTO) in lieu of paid overtime, subject to the foregoing requirements and restrictions. Compensatory time off earned will accrue at one and one-half (1.5) times hours worked. CTO may be elected for overtime incurred due to professional training time only. Maximum CTO accrual will be 100 hours. All overtime earned after CTO is accrued to the 100-hour maximum will be paid in cash Accrued CTO may be cashed out upon the request of the Fire Marshal and the approval of the department. CTO accrued at time of separation will be paid off. CTO may be taken off upon Fire Marshal request and department approval CTO will not be approved if it will require overtime. 29.2. Vacation Leave. All leave time (vacation sick leave, holiday, etc.) must be taken on an hour -for -hour basis, equaling actual time off, regardless of accumulation rates. Dui ing the term of this AGRFEMENT, paid vacation leave for the Fire Marshal position shall be earned at the following rate: SERVICE YEARS ENTITLEMENT IN DAYS 1 thru 2 10 3 thru 4 11 5 thru 6 12 7 thru 8 13 9 thru 10 14 11 thru 12 15 13 thru 14 16 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU 15 thru 16 17 thru 18 19 thru 20 21 or more 17 18 19 20 The standard for vacation time is eight (8) hours equals one (1) day. The Fire Marshal may exercise an option to convert into cash a maximum of forty (40) hours of accrued vacation leave each fiscal year. Such conversion shall be computed at the employee's current base hourly rate, on an hour -per -hour basis. Unused vacation leave may be carried over, into the following year, to a maximum of two hundred twenty (220) hours. In the event the Fire Marshal exceeds the 220-hour maximum as of the pay period containing November 1 of each year, they will have the following options related to the excess hours: a, b. c. Cash out; Convert hours to sick leave on an hour -for -hour basis; and/or Paid to deferred compensation. The CITY shalt take said action(s) with the pay period containing December 1 of each year. Payment shall be computed, based upon the employee s base hourly rate of pay as of June 30 of the same calendar year. In the event of separation from the CITY, the Fire Marshal shall be entitled to pay for accumulated vacation, prior to separation, at their current base hourly rate of pay. 29.3 Holiday Leave. For the purpose of this AGREEMFNT, the following days are the holidays for the employee in the Fire Marshal position: Independence Day Labor Day Veteran's Day Thanksgiving Day Day after Thanksgiving Day Christmas Day New Year's Day Martin Luther King, Jr., Day Lincoln's Birthday President's Day Memorial Day Floating Holiday Floating Holiday July 4 1st Monday in September November 11 4th Thursday in November 4th Friday in November December 25 January 1 3rd Monday in January February 12 3rd Monday in February Last Monday in May Varies Varies 01 /81.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU Holidays falling on Saturday shall be observed on the preceding Friday and holidays falling on Sunday shall be observed on the following Monday. Such observed holidays shall be considered designated holidays for purposes of overtime. One holiday equals eight (8) hours. It is agreed that when a holiday is proclaimed by the Mayor of the CITY, the Fire Marshal shall be granted time -off in the same number of equivalent work hours. Such times -off shall authorized by the Fite Chief. The Fire Marshal may accumulate up to a maximum of forty --eight (48) hours of holiday time. Hours of holiday time, accumulated over 48 hours will be paid off. When the Fire Marshal terminates employment with the CITY, they shall receive pay for their current holiday balance, up to a maximum of 48 hours, at their current base hourly rate. CITY's denial of requested holiday time off shall be neither arbitrary nor capricious. The first payroll including July 1, the Fire Marshal's leave bank will be credited with 16 hours floating holiday. MORRO BAY FIRE FIGHTERS ASS'N, CITY OF MORRO BAY IAFF LOCAL 3725 Michael IIo_ese Tra Ilasch `Stott Subler Scott tollins, City Manager Crk Colin Tanner, Deputy City Attorney/Lead Negotiator L 01. 444 Dana Swanson, City Cleric ♦411fi curie ofortl HunResources Analyst 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay I i►'cfiglitem Association 2020 - 2022 h1OU Holidays falling on Saturday shall be observed on the preceding Friday and holidays failing on Sunday shall be observed on the following Monday. Such observed holidays shall be considered designated holidays for purposes of overtime. One holiday equals eight (8) hours. It is agreed that when a holiday is proclaimed by the Mayor of the CITY, the Fire Marshal shall be granted time -off in the salve number of equivalent work hours. Such time -off shall authorized by the Fire Chief. The Fire Marshal may accumulate up to a maximum of forty-eight (48) hours of holiday time. Hours of holiday time, accumulated over 48 hours will be paid off. When the Fire Marshal terminates employment with the CITY, they shall receive pay for their current holiday balance, up to a maximum of 48 hours, at their current base hourly rate. CITY's denial of requested holiday time off shall be neither arbitrary nor capricious. The first payroll including July 1, the Fire Marshal's leave bank will be credited with 16 hours floating holiday. MORRO BAY FIRE FIGHTERS ASS'N, CITY OF MORRO BAY IAFF LOCAL 3725 Michael Ho se N.,...., Tra' Hasch ott Subler Scott Collins, City Manager Colin Tanner, Deputy City Attorney/Lead Negotiator Dana Swanson, City Clerk Laurie Goforth, Human Resources Analyst 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU EXHIBIT A CITY OF MORRO BAY FY 20/21 MBFFA SALARY SCHEDULE Effective July 1, 2020 through Octobei 2, 2020 and January 1, 2021 through June 30, 2021 TITLE STEP 1 STEP 2 STEP 3 STEP 4 STEP 5 FIREFIGHTER 59,065 62,018 65,119 68,375 71,794 FIRE ENGINEER 64,573 67,802 71,192 74,751 78,489 FIRE CAPTAIN 74,227 77,938 81,835 85,927 90,223 FIRE MARSHAL 88,114 92,520 97,146 102,003 107,103 Note: The parties agreed to a 5% salary reduction for Unit members for the period of October 3 2020 through December 31, 2020 pursuant to the Side Letter Agreement between the CITY and MBFFA Regarding Successor MOU Negotiations and Temporary Salary Negotiations. The 5% salary reduction for Unit members ceased on December 31, 2020. 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU I-4,XHIBIT B CITY OF MORRO BAY FY 21/22 MBFFA SALARY SCHEDULE Effective July 1, 2021 TITLE STEP 1 STEP 2 STEP 3 STEP 4 STEP 5 FIREFIGHTER 62,018 65,119 68,375 71,794 75,384 FIRE ENGINEER 67,802 71,192 74,751 78,489 82,413 FIRE CAPTAIN 77,938 81,835 85,927 90,223 94,735 FIRE MARSHAL 92,520 97,146 102,003 107,103 112,458 01181.0026/708071.4 Morro Bay Firefighters Association 2020 - 2022 MOU